Return-Path: <@CS.CMU.EDU:Hans.Tallis@LATEEN.PC.CS.CMU.EDU>
Received: from CS.CMU.EDU by K.GP.CS.CMU.EDU; 23 May 89 16:11:53 EDT
Received: from LATEEN.PC.CS.CMU.EDU by CS.CMU.EDU; 23 May 89 16:09:31 EDT
Date: Tue, 23 May 1989 16:08-EDT 
From: Hans.Tallis@ML.RI.CMU.EDU
To: bovik@cs
Subject: tent buying advice
Message-Id: <611957283/tallis@LATEEN.PC.CS.CMU.EDU>

Harry,
Going camping?  --Hans

Well, I've learned a lot about tents in the past week or so.  Thanks again to
everyone who replied.  I hope this information will prove of value to others.

A good sourcebook is Colin Fletcher's The Complete Walker, available at
popular bookstores.  It is generally considered the backpacker's bible, and
from the little I've read in it, it deserves the title.  Colin's view of tents
isn't too favorable; he seems to do generally without them whenever possible.
In the summer they are most useful for keeping bugs off.  Rain can often be
handled without resorting to a full tent.

Below I summarize responses; near the end is a nifty spreadsheet evaluation of
lots of different 2-man tent models.  It basically combines weight, size, and
price information into an overall rating for a variety of tents.  (To print it
out, try "enscript -1 -r -fCourier5 tent.info".)  It ignores more features
than it includes, however, so don't just pick the winner and buy it.  Also
there are probably some data entry errors (corrections welcome).

There are a bewildering number of features to look for in a tent.  The
original mail messages below discuss them in more detail; check them for the
full story.
	weight
	price
	height/volume
	vestibule? (useful for shielding packs and drying clothes)
	warranty
	full-covering fly vs. partial
	ease of setting up
	wind resistance (varies inversely with volume)
	bathtub floor?  seams?
	workmanship quality
	flow-through ventilation
	ease of entry
	seasons:  1/3/4
	pole quality

For the novice camper, it seems the consensus advice is to go buy a cheap tent
and get some experience before investing in a several hundred dollar model.
The local Sears and KMart stores stock $50 tents.  At least two people report
satisfaction with this quality of tent.  If you're car camping, you always
have the option of just driving to the closest motel if the weather is really
bad.  It's also possible to rent tents; this gives you a chance to try several
models before buying one.

If you want a better tent, I heartily recommend spending some time talking to
the people at Outdoor Experience (if you're here in Pittsburgh).  Their prices
are competitive (they'll match any advertised price) and they stock a large
variety of tents, so you'll want to buy from there anyway.

-------------------------------------------------------------mails

From: Paul Christopher Workman <pw0l+@andrew.cmu.edu>
Have you considered army surplus?

I can't help wondering if what you're looking for isn't
really available, and that you might have to go for the
kind of tent that people can stand up in, as opposed to
one where people can sit in.  My parents had a tent like
that, which had a "ceiling" about 5'6" on the sides to 8" in the
middle.  It could "house" or "tent" about 6 or 8 people if it
was so desired.  If you'll be carrying the tent on the top of
your car, perhaps you should get one of these kinds of tents.
paul


From: Rick Kazman <Rick.Kazman@CAD.CS.CMU.EDU>
Hans,  

I would like to put my vote in for two things:  

1) buy your tent from Outdoor Experience--they're competitively priced,
convenient, reasonable people, and I think that we should support local
business, assuming that we don't have to take too much of a beating to do
so.  I bought my backpack from them, and it was the exact same price as
Campmor charged.

2) buy a two man tent.  In backpacking, I feel that less is more, if you get
my drift.  I've carried some very heavy packs, and regretted every item I
had where I purchased a cheaper, heavier model than I really needed.  This,
of course, changes depending on the type of camping that you want to do.  If
you're doing car camping (as I suspect :-), then buy that all canvas 6
person tent, otherwise, buy the lightest two-man that you can get away with.
Three man tents are always tight for three men (I'm speaking from experience
here).

rick

From: Stephen.Wadlow@CAD.CS.CMU.EDU

Hmm. the main thing that comes to mind is have a floor that actually
rides up the wall 3-4" and is made of a pretty tough, waterproof
material.  This will help to keep you and your equipment dry.  On
the same topic, the less seams you have in the floor, the better 
you off you are.  Nothing else major comes to mind (i'm not really
with it right now...) but I recommend getting a campmor catalog
(I may have an old one, but I doubt it...) and seeing what they
have in comparison to the outdoor experience.  OE will match campmores
pricing, and you get to see the tents beforehand.

			steve

From: Larry.Matthies@IUS1.CS.CMU.EDU

Hans,

I have a Eureka Timberline, two-person model, that I bought about six
years ago for less than $120.  It weights about 7 pounds.  Its easy to
set up, comfortable for two, and generally very satisfactory.  As you
may find from other responses, it is a very popular tent.  I think its
one of the best price-performers around; price-wise, its at the low end
of the "decent" class of backpacking tents.

	Larry

From: Eugene Miya <eugene@eos.arc.nasa.gov>

I don't know.  Get something light.  Don't depend on Brand names.
Get something cheap, oh, I know, ANALYZE your REQUIREMENTS!
Like are you going to use in winter?  Then decide on that basis.
3-man tents.

Humm, there was a general rule 3 lbs per person.  Year ago I
got a Sierra Designs 3-Man.  It's 8 lbs.  But you can stand in it,
so its light.  No longer made.  I frequently use it with only 2 people,
and frequently squeeze 4 in it.  Its also good in winter.

--enm

From: chucks@acdpyr.UCAR.EDU (Chuck Smythe)

My experience, for what it's worth:

For the sort of use you describe, you want to look for
1)light
2) easy to set up, especially in a wind
3) light
4) something like a vestibule to get muddy boots, etc out of the rain
5) light
6) durable
7) light 
I personally like my North Face Westwind a lot (it qualifies on all the counts
above) but it is a bit on the expensive side if you're not into Serious
Backpacking.  If you don't camp in cold and windy places very much, several
models are made mostly of mosquito netting and are even lighter than the
5 1/2 lbs. of my tent. (And maybe cheaper.)  Free-standing tents are nice
on count 2, especially if you have to pitch one in an awkward place, but
I've never found one with a vestibule.  If money is a serious problem, Eureka
tents seem to be relatively cheap and well made (but not especially light).
The cheapest sources seem to be REI and Campmor.
   Hope this is of some use to you.   
-- Chuck Smythe
           

From: "Roger Hayes" <rogerh@arizona.edu>


My experience is that I am very sensitive to weight on a bike -- more
so than on foot, oddly enough -- and I spend less time in the tent
on a bike trip, since there are usually picnic shelters & so forth.
So I say, if it's primarily a bike tent, go as light as you can.

After all, if the weather is truly miserable, you should be in a motel
anyway.  That option does not exist on most backpacking trips.

				Roger Hayes
				rogerh@arizona.edu

From: johnson@eceugs.ncsu.edu (Amy Johnson)

Hi. I have a Sierra Designs Sleeve Flashlite.  I used it for a cross-country
bike tour and it worked great.  It is ~4 lbs and incredibly easy to set up.
The only complaint I had was that ventilation wasn't great on hot nights, but
I'm not sure that anyone's tent was any better since we all ended up sleeping
on picnic tables those steamy nights.

Amy <johnson%eceugs@ncsuvx.ncsu.edu>

From: mhf@briar.philips.com (Myron Frommer;6270;2.12;$0143)

I am looking for advice on a tent style. I've been considering the following
Eureka tents: Wind River 6 (dome), Alpine Meadows 6 (self-supporting A-frame
with center hoop) and the Willow Creek 2/4/6 series umbrella.

The considerations I have are (in no particular order):
1) Must be able to stand up in it.
2) One tent is for 2 adults, the other for 5 kids, ages 5 to 14.
3) Room for gear.
4) Good rain resistance.
5) Ease in set-up and take-down.

>From what I can gather there may be more walk-around room and useful corners in
the dome than the A-frame.  Two A-frames would require less site area than two
domes.  The umbrella has better ventilation, but how about rain protection? It
may also be a bit high in the center for someone 5'6" to put up easily.

I've used the Wind River 6 for the kids, and it also did well in an awful
storm.  Just got a bit steamy at night with the kids +1 adult.

Any advice will be appreciated.

P.S. While we're asking for advice, are there any advantages of liquid fuel vs
propane for Coleman lanterns and stoves?

From: lasala@svax.cs.cornell.edu (Steve LaSala)

In article <4995@pt.cs.cmu.edu> you write:
>
>I'm looking to buy a two-man tent with enough room inside for both to sit in.
>It would be for general purpose use, perhaps for bike touring, and maybe
>light-duty backpacking.  I'm new to this game, so I'm looking for some advice.
>
>	- What are good brand names?
Eureka, Moss, Walrus, Bibler, Sierra Designs, The North Face
>
>	- Where should I buy from?  Mail order?  Local retailer?
Depends.  I don't know how outdoor-oriented Pittsburgh is, or in what style.
Most "outdoorsmen's" or "hunting and camping" stores won't have the lightweight
stuff you seem to be looking for.  Try an outdoor specialty store, or try
ordering from REI, Beans, Campmor.  It's a bit of a trip for you, but if you're
up this way, Eureka (one of the largest US manufacturers) has a factory and
off-price store in Binghampton NY.
>
>	- What sort of features should I look for in a good tent?
shock-corded poles, fine (no-see-um) netting, free standing is nice but not
essential, 'bathtub' floor, flow-through ventilation, a door at each end is
helpful
>
>	- Should I look instead for a 3-man?
Many people discount the stated capacity by one, but if you want to stuff this
thing in bike bags, you probably want to go for light weight and small size at
the expense of interior space.  Figure about 20 sq. ft. per person minimum.

From: Hal Lillywhite <hall@vice.ico.tek.com>

A lot of people would consider my advice herasey (SP?) but if you're
just getting started get about the cheapest 3 person dome tent you
can find (k-mart or similar stores or discount places).  Unless you
are out in really nasty weather it will do fine for a while.  

While you're wearing it out (and maybe deciding if you really want
to get serious about this activity) talk to other people about what
they have, what they like about it, what they don't like, how much
it cost and where, etc.  Also save all the good advice you will get
in response to your query.  Then in a year or 2 you will have a much
better idea what you want for how you want to use it.  Unless you
have an unlimited budget DO NOT buy an expensive tent to start with.

Another option is to rent a variety of tents before you buy so you
can try out various styles/brands.

BTW, in my experience most "3 man" tents would probably be fine for
3 small children although 3 adults can fit inside in a pinch.

Enjoy!


From: Edward Czeck <ewc@setter.ece.cmu.edu>

Probably the best place to get advice is to go to a good outdoor store,
(Outdoor Experience in Shadyside or Exkursion in Monroeville) and ask to
see tents.  Tell them what you want, etc.   It's their job and they love
doing it.

If you are looking for a tent to sit, in rather than just sleep,  then you
will probably want a dome tent (maximum volume with minimum surface area).
These and most others tent (and camping supplies) come in three qualities:
cheap,  quality at an affordable price, and Mt Everest quality.   Cheap you
can get at K-mart, or any other department store.  The design quality is
modified for lower cost,  these are good, if you don't mind getting wet when
it rains hard, and only want the tent to last a few years, at regular use.
The second category is probably where you want to shop, and is the largest
market.  The Mt Everest class is only if you want to spend a fortune, or
plan to camp in gale force wind, rain, and expect the roof to hold a ton of
snow.

If I were shopping for a tent, in your case, I would go to both Outdoor
Experience and Exkursion, to look at tents and know what is available, and
the cost etc.  It would also be worthwhile to look at a catalog from
Campmore (Somewhere in NJ) and REI (Seattle WA) to get a larger selection
and table comparisons of the tents.  You may also want to look at K-mart or
and army/navy store to see their selections, and decide what features you
can live without for the lower cost.  

My only requirements for a tent are:  it must have a rain fly which covers
to the ground, and I must be able to sit up inside of the tent.  Free
standing tents, and windows, front and back, for ventilation are also
important features.  

Please forward your responses to Bovik

Happy Camping

Ed.

From: alpope@Sun.COM (Alan L. Pope)

Over the last few months I went through this same process.  With the selection
available I finally threw my hands up in the air and...oh! yeah, what about a
decision matrix with multiplan.  I am going to try including the spreadsheet I
did, hopefully the mailer won't barf.

Basically, I needed a two man tent. I set the upper weight for inclusion at 9
lbs. (anything 9 or more not included).  Each category was scaled from 1-10
based on the entries in the category.  The categories were what was important
to me.  If you get what is called a two man you may want a vestibule because
two man tents usually only fit two w/ no gear space.  Let me know if you more
info or if this gets trashed.

<updated, included below --Hans>

Date: Wed, 17 May 89 13:42:52 CDT
From: mjt@wuee1.wustl.edu (Mike Turmon)
To: tallis@LATEEN.PC.CS.CMU.EDU
Subject: Re: tent buying advice?
Cc: 

I have successfully gone bike touring with a Sierra Designs Clip
Flashlight.  It is a two-man tent with enough room for both to
sit inside--but not for a long time without getting cramped.
It has a rain fly which does not have to be on the tent if it is
not raining.  This is a good thing because it can get hot without 
ventilation.  

It is a well-made product.  It stood up to some very heavy winds
and rain without trouble, and to the wear and tear of 5 weeks of
using it every night.  The real feature of the tent, though, is that
it is easy to put up because the tent has clips which you attach to
the tent poles instead of threading the poles through the tent
fabric.  The result is that it is very easy and quick to put up and down.
This is a good thing if you use the tent a lot.  Any delay or fuss
getting the thing up quickly becomes irritating.

The clip Flashlight is very, you know, light.  A shade over 3 lbs
including poles.  The major disadvantage that I know of is that
it is not free-standing--it wants to be staked in to the ground.
This is not a problem if you are camping on a reasonable surface.
We camped in sand once with no problem, and never found a surface too 
hard to take stakes.  (Powder snow might be a problem.  Fine, dry sand
might also mean trouble.)

I guess another disadvantage is that it is kind of expensive, about 
$150.  This is not wildly expensive, but there are cheaper tents.

About buying tents.  There is a mailorder outfit called Campmor that
sells all manner of tents cheaply.  I can find their address if you
need it.  

In summary--Get a tent that is light, that is easy to put up and take
down, and that will stand up to rain and wind.  A rain fly that
attaches securely and covers the entire tent is a good mechanism
to allow you to be cool and have rain protection when you need it.

If you feel good about the Flashlight (You may well hear other good
things about it.  It is a pretty popular tent.) then it would be
reasonable to get it through a mailorder outfit like Campmor.  If you
feel like you still need help, then go to one of the outdoors places
in PGH and ask for advice.  (If you do that then it is the morally
upstanding thing to buy the tent from them.)

If you want another enthusiastic recommendation, try Alan Chung
(Alan.Chung@k.gp.cs.cmu.edu -- "research scientist" on the Mach 
project).  I toured with him and we used his Flashlight.

Mike Turmon
mjt@hyperion.wustl.edu

From: mhf@philabs.Philips.Com  (Myron Frommer)

I've found the best prices for Eureka tents at REI, even BEFORE considering
the member rebate at the end of the year. 

Their # is 1-800-426-4840

You can yet a Eureka catalog from Eureka 1-607-779-2200
There may be an 800 line call 800-555-1212. Eureka is also listed as Johnson
Camping Equip. in Binghamton, NY

Myron Frommer

From: skorstad@p.cs.uiuc.edu

Sierra Designs has just come out with a tent that I think has some
excellent features.  It's called the Super Flash.  It's basically
a souped-up version of their "Clip Flashlight".  It weighs 5 lbs,
4 oz, is more comfortable for two adults than the Clip, and...is
a FOUR season tent costing about $215 (at Campmor).

The design of the tent is similar to the North Face "Westwind", only
a lot cheaper and (probably) easier to pitch.  The "Swift Clip" method
of attaching the tent body to the poles has made setting up camp a lot
easier.  I used to own a Eureka "Alpine Meadows".  Pitching that tent,
especially when windy, was a hassle.  Plus, it was overweight.

In general, I recommend the following tent manufacturers:

   Sierra Designs
   North Face
   Moss

If you have a lot of $$$ to spend, consider Bibler tents...undoubtably
among the lightest tents around.  I'm generally not too impressed with
Eureka tents.  Their early A-frame designs aren't competitive in terms
of strength and weight.  And their new tents are basically copies of
designs innovated by the above three companies.

G. Skorstad
U. Illinois

From: jwa@beta.lanl.gov (Wayne Anderson)

About the time I moved to New Mexico (11 years ago), Backpacker Magazine
ran an article rating 3 season tents.  Their hands down choice was the
Sierra Design Aeroflex (I'm hoping I remember the name right - I just
backpack with it).  As I was in need of a new tent, I went out and bought
one and have been extremely happy with it.  The rain fly is attached to
the tent permanently and helps make this tent extremely easy to pitch.  In
fact I've yet to backpack with anyone that didn't envy the speed with which
it goes up, particularly when the clouds are building.  The only complaint
I can come up with is that the tent is unstable (as are most A frame tents)
in high winds unless pitched longitudinally with the direction of the wind.
This really was only a problem once when my wife and I were caught in a
severe snow/thunderstorm at 12,000' in the Weminuche.  The wind switched
directions and totally flattened the tent.  When the storm endend (~10 min.)
it popped back up and we were back in business with no harm done.

The only problem I have recommending this tent is that I haven't seen it
marketed in a few years.  REI used to make a look-alike but I haven't
seen it recently in their catalogs.  Anyone know what happened?

I was recently at the new REI store in Albuquerque looking for a tent
for a friend in Austin (he wanted an Aeroflex).  The Sierra Design Flashlight
looks like a pretty good option at a good price.  Just from looking at
it, it appears a bit small for two adults, however.  Anyone have experience
with it?

Wayne

From: moore%cdr.utah.edu@wasatch.utah.edu (Tim Moore)

In article <24473@beta.lanl.gov> jwa@beta.lanl.gov (Wayne Anderson) writes:
}
}I was recently at the new REI store in Albuquerque looking for a tent
}for a friend in Austin (he wanted an Aeroflex).  The Sierra Design Flashlight
}looks like a pretty good option at a good price.  Just from looking at
}it, it appears a bit small for two adults, however.  Anyone have experience
}with it?

My parents have a Flashlight and are quite happy with it. It's cozy
for two, no question, but certainly adequate for them. They love its
light weight and its ease in setting up.
}Wayne


Tim Moore                     moore@cs.utah.edu {ut-sally,hplabs}!utah-cs!moore
"Y'know, sometimes I wonder - does existence precede essence? Or what?"
		-Cherry Poptart

From: stout@hpl-opus.HP.COM (Cheryl Stout)


>  I was recently at the new REI store in Albuquerque looking for a tent
>  for a friend in Austin (he wanted an Aeroflex).  The Sierra Design Flashlight
>  looks like a pretty good option at a good price.  Just from looking at
>  it, it appears a bit small for two adults, however.  Anyone have experience
>  with it?
>  
>  Wayne
>  ----------

I bought a Sierra Designs Sleeve Flashlight last year and used it on a few
trips last summer.  In general, I am very pleased with it.  Two people can
sleep comfortably, but there is no room for gear.  There isn't much room to
sit up in, but there is ample floor space for two large adults.  It weighs 
3lb. 9oz. and is very easy to set up.  It uses 2 poles and must be staked
down - not a free-standing design.  One feature that is both good and 
bad is the way the tent slopes at the entrance.  You can unzip the opening
and look up and see the stars while you are laying in your bag.  On the 
other hand, if the weather is wet, this means that opening the entrance 
results in some water getting onto the floor of the tent.  I was in some 
fairly strong winds with hail and snow at 12,000' and the tent had no problems. 
I did seal all the seams myself - as recommended. I think the tent is great 
for the price - I paid $99 at REI.


Cheryl


From: simon@nova.laic.uucp (Simon Kao)

Someone mentioned the Sierra Designs Flashlight. It's small. Actually,
it's thin. The length is fine, but two large-size humans would be cozy.

I also used to use a Sierra West tent that had an integral fly (and a
screen roof. OK for a quick setup, but no good in the rain. The fly 
was good for dew, but that was about it. They don't make it anymore
anyway.

I'm also thinking of buying a tent (the previous two were borrowed).
While shopping around, I happened to overhear a couple talking things
over with the salesperson. They were looking at a tent that was not 
free-standing. "Honey," says the male, "I think we need a free-standing
tent. Remember when we were at the Matterhorn and couldn't find a place
to pitch our tent?" She mumbled something. 

Anyway, perhaps he wasn't just name-dropping. In any case, how 'bout 
that for a discussion topic? I haven't yet been to a place where a
free-standing tent was absolutely necessary (but then again, I've
never had to use an old-fashioned tent that needed a zillion stakes
to make it stand up, either).

--Simon Kao
  ...!{lll-lcc, pyramid}!leadsv!laic!cosmos!kao


From: engber@shorty.CS.WISC.EDU (Mike Engber)

I own the Mobile Dome by Sierra West. REI is running it on mail order sale
for 149.99 in their caming '89 catalog.

some points about it:
+ it has factory sealed seams
+ it is a four season tent
+ it has zip close mesh ceiling for summer use
- it has pole sleaves instead of swift clips
- it weighs 7 lb 7oz - a little heavy for 2 people

They also have the Litehouse & Guest House on sale. On the net I recall
reading something about Sierra West going under. This may explain the sale.

As far as I know, Sierra West makes the only tents with factory sealed seams.
Why doesn't anyone else. If Sierra Designs made a seam sealed tent with
swift clips it seems like they'd have a big seller since those are the
two features I want in a tent (I haven't actually used swift clips, but they
sound so good - they have to be better than sleaves - anyone care to comment?)

-ME


From: carnes@ico.ISC.COM (Steve Carnes)

In article <7557@spool.cs.wisc.edu> engber@shorty.cs.wisc.edu (Mike Engber) writes:
>
>I own the Mobile Dome by Sierra West. REI is running it on mail order sale
>for 149.99 in their caming '89 catalog.
>
>They also have the Litehouse & Guest House on sale. On the net I recall
>reading something about Sierra West going under. This may explain the sale.

I own one as well and love it!  Easy to pitch, reasonably bombproof in windy
conditions, and dry as a cracker in wet.  (It's also a nice light blue color,
to answer the concerns of another poster!)  I wanted a vestibule for it and
called Sierra West, but the woman there told me they were getting out of the
tentmaking business.  So a week ago, I found an REI vestibule on sale for
$20 and, with only the minor additions of some velcro, it's going to work
just fine.

Another person asked if a truly freestanding tent is necessary.  No, but it's
nice.  In desert camping, it's sometimes difficult to find either ground
*soft* enough to push in the stakes, or ground *hard* enough to hold the
stakes once pushed in.  In severe winds, a non-freestander will collapse if
the stakes pull out.  One last advantage is the ability to pick up the whole
damn thing, invert it, and shake out all the dirt and sand before collapsing
it packing it away.


From: clindh@bally.Bally.COM (Christer Lindh)

In article <564@laic.UUCP> simon@nova.laic.uucp (Simon Kao) writes:
>
>   Someone mentioned the Sierra Designs Flashlight. It's small. Actually,
>   it's thin. The length is fine, but two large-size humans would be cozy.
>
I recently bought a Sierra Design Bike Light, a 3-season free-standing
tent with clips instead of sleeves, it weighs something like 3.5
pounds. I choosed between that and the Flashlight, and took the Bike
Light as it is freestanding and has headroom. It's also a little lighter.
It costed me $150. There's also a little larger version of this tent
called "Half Moon".

Took it out to Lovers Leap this weekend, it worked just fine. Very
easy to pitch, enough room for two if you like each other... It's
propably not the best tent in nasty weather though, the fly does not
go all the way to the ground.
--
clindh@bally.COM                  ::         
Bally Systems, Reno, NV,          ::            BOYCOTT GRAVITY
(702) 323-6156                    ::


From: marks%ssdevo.DEC.COM@mountn.dec.com

The most recent edition of the REI Camping catalog has several new tent
designs.

Also, I found the Strength Index ratings for each tent a useful
addition to the comparison figures.  The higher the Strength Index, the
more resistantance to being flattened by wind.  An index of 40 corresponds
roughly to being able to reliably withstand 40mph winds.

Randy


From: bgreen@zodiac.ADS.COM (Barbara Green)

I became a big fan of free-standing tents a couple of years ago when
my friends all were able to pitch their tents on high (hard!) ground,
but I had to pitch my Moss on softer, lower ground near a meadow.  The
next morning, my daughter and I were covered with ICE, while my
friends were dry as a bone.  Now I have a Sierra Designs Stretched
Dome that I really like -- free-standing, good in a wind, sleeps 3,
and weighs 7 lbs. 10 oz., including vestibule and fly.

	Barbara Green

---------------------------------------lots of tent data, 210 cols wide-------
------------for some sorting, cat through "sort 0.205n" or "sort 0.195n"------

by Alan L. Pope
updated, reformatted by Hans Tallis
----------------------------------------
Weight Points Key:		(180-weight)/12.5
Sqr Ft Points Key:		(SqFt-21)/4.5
Height Points Key:		(Ht-39)/1.7
Price Points Key:		(400-price)/31
Shape Points Key:		Slant=0, tube=1, tunnel=2, dome=3
Vestibule Points Key:		none=0, attached=1, detached=2
Seasons Points Key:		two=0, three=1, 3.5=2, four=3  (a lot of questionable entries below)

"Physical Points" includes all but Price Points.
For the continuous attributes, $31 = 12.5oz = 4.5sqft = 1.7in-height
REI, North Face, Walrus, Eureka, North Face/Windy Pass, LL Bean, Gregory, Moss, Sears, Sierra Design
-------------------------------------

Tent Name                Tent   Vestibule Total  Square Vestibule Total     Tent   Tent   Vestibule Total                                 Total Wt Tot Sqr Ft Height Price  Vestibule Seasons Shape   TOTAL       Physical      
                         Weight Weight    Weight Feet   Square Ft Square Ft Height Price  Price     Price  Vestibule Seasons Shape        Points   Points     Points Points Points    Points  Points  POINTS      Points        
===================================================================================================================================       ==========================================================  ==========  ========      
REI  Mountain Hut-2      122    14        136    52.8   8         60.8      47     200.00 50.00     250.00 2         1       4            4        9          5      5      2         3       3       31          26            
REI  Geo Dome 2          133    32        165    42.5   12        54.5      48     149.00 30.00     179.00 2         1       3            1        7          5      7      2         1       3       26          19            
REI  Mountain Home       126    0         126    31.3   0         31.3      48     250.00 0.00      250.00 1         1       2            4        2          5      5      1         1       2       20          15            
REI  Dome                110    0         110    41     0         41        52     150.00 0.00      150.00 0         1       3            6        4          8      8      0         1       3       30          22            
REI  Taymor Hosteller    67     0         67     34     0         34        42     100.00 0.00      100.00 0         1       0            9        3          2      10     0         1       0       25          15            
REI  Diamond Free Spirit 108    22        130    35     10.5      45.5      42     100.00 20.00     120.00 2         1       1            4        5          2      9      2         1       1       24          15            
REI  ET-2 Hobitat        102    0         102    36     0         36        45     400.00 0.00      400.00 0         4       3            6        3          4      0      0         3       3       19          19
REI  Trail Dome          100    0         100    41     0         41        52     125.00 0.00      125.00 0         3       3            6        4          7      9      0         1       3       30          23
REI  Clipper 2           117    0         117    42.8   0         42.8      51.5   150.00 0.00      150.00 0         3       3            5        5          7      8      0         1       3       29          21
NF   Bull Frog           99.5   0         99.5   35     0         35        45     330.00 0.00      330.00 0         1       0            6        3          4      2      0         1       0       16          14            
NF   Westwind            94     0         94     32     8         40        44     325.00 0.00      325.00 1         4       2            7        4          3      2      1         3       2       22          20            
NF   Tadpole             64     0         64     27     0         27        39     260.00 0.00      260.00 0         1       1            9        1          0      5      0         1       1       17          12            
NF   Boulder             140    ?         140    43     7.3       50.3      46     400.00 0.00      400.00 1         4       3            3        7          4      0      1         3       3       21          21
NF   Salamander          90    0?         90     36     0         36        42     240.00 0.00      240.00 0         3       3            8        3          2      5      0         1       3       22          17
NFWP VE-23               134    0         134    43     7         50        46     300.00 0.00      300.00 1         1       3            4        6          4      3      1         1       3       22          19            
NFWP Dragon Fly          88     0         88     44.9   0         44.9      43     185.00 0.00      185.00 0         1       0            7        5          2      7      0         1       0       22          15            
NFWP 23                  112    0         112    43     0         43        46     200.00 0.00      200.00 0         1       3            5        5          4      6      0         1       3       24          18            
NFWP Skeeter             112    0         112    43     0         43        46     220.00 0.00      220.00 0         1       3            5        5          4      6      0         1       3       24          18            
NFWP Trekker 24          136    28        164    43     9         52        49     240.00 49.99     289.99 2         3       3            1        7          6      4      2         3       3       26          22            
SD   Bike Light          55     0         55     27     0         27        41     149.99 0.00      149.99 0         0       2            10       1          1      8      0         0       2       22          14            
SD   Half Moon           70     0         70     32     0         32        46     189.99 0.00      189.99 0         1       2            9        2          4      7      0         1       2       25          18            
SD   Clip Flashlight     61     0         61     34     0         34        43     99.99  0.00      99.99  0         1       0            10       3          2      10     0         1       0       26          16            
SD   Super Flash         85     0         85     34     0         34        45     215.00 0.00      215.00 0         3       2            8        3          4      6      0         3       2       26          20            
SD   Meteor Light        92     0         92     40     0         40        46     189.99 0.00      189.99 0         1       2            7        4          4      7      0         1       2       25          18            
SD   Comet               111    0         111    50     0         50        53     249.99 0.00      249.99 0         1       2            6        6          8      5      0         1       2       28          23            
SD   Stretch Dome        123    9         132    46     8         54        51     279.99 48.00     327.99 2         3       2            4        7          7      2      2         3       2       27          25            
SD   Clip Dome 2-B       106    0         106    45     0         45        48     199.99 0.00      199.99 0         1       2            6        5          5      6      0         1       2       25          19            
Wal  Orbit               117    16        133    44.5   12        56.5      45     325.00 40.00     365.00 2         4       3            4        8          4      1      2         3       3       25          24            
Wal  Rocket              78     16        94     38     12        50        43     199.00 40.00     239.00 2         3       2            7        6          2      5      2         1       2       25          20            
Wal  Lightyear           52     14        64     40     12        52        43     165.00 50.00     215.00 2         3       1            9        7          2      6      2         1       1       28          22            
Wal  Moonrock            107    0         107    35     0         35        42     0.00   0.00      0.00   0         3       3            6        3          2      ?      0         1       3       ?           17
Greg Mountaineer II      107    0         107    38     0         38        42     399.00 0.00      399.00 0         4       3            6        4          2      0      0         3       3       18          18
Greg Serenity Base       91     0         91     38     0         38        43     359.00 0.00      359.00 0         3       3            8        4          2      1      0         1       3       19          18
Greg Solitary Base       63     0         63     29     0         29        36     0.00   0.00      0.00   0         2       3            10       1          -2     ?      0         0       3       ?           12
Moss Stardome II         ?      ?        102     36     9         45        ?      0.00   0.00      0.00   1         4       3            7        5          5?     ?      1         3       3       ?           23
Moss Startrak            ?      ?        104     35     14        49        ?      0.00   0.00      0.00   1         3       3            6        6          5?     ?      1         1       3       ?           21
Moss Stargazer           ?      ?        108     41.2   10.9      52.1      ?      0.00   0.00      0.00   1         3       3            6        7          5?     ?      1         1       3       ?           22
Moss Starlet II          ?      ?        78      29     8.5       37.5      39     280.00 0.00      280.00 1         3       2            8        4          0      4      1         1       2       20          16
Moss Olympic             ?      ?        116     42.5   13        55.5      52     410.00 0.00      410.00 1         4       3            5        8          8      ?      1         3       3       27          27
Eur  Cirrus              64     0         64     29     0         29        45     119.99 0.00      119.99 0         1       0            9        0          4      9      0         1       0       23          14            
Eur  Skyline             104    0         104    41     0         41        46     299.00 0.00      299.00 1         1       3            6        4          4      3      1         1       3       22          19            
Eur  Alpine Meadows      122    16        138    37.6   14        51.6      48     140.00 28.00     168.00 2         1       1            3        7          5      7      2         1       1       26          19            
Eur  Traverse            123    36        159    37.5   17        54.5      41     280.00 65.00     345.00 2         3       3            2        7          1      2      2         3       3       20          18            
Eur  Timberline          111    16        127    37.6   10.5      48.1      42     109.99 26.95     136.94 2         1       1            4        6          2      8      2         1       1       24          16            
Eur  Outfitter           135    16        151    37.6   10.5      48.1      42     164.95 29.00     193.95 2         3       1            2        6          2      7      2         3       1       23          16            
Eur  Timberline Deluxe   124    16        140    40     10.5      50.5      42     159.99 29.00     188.99 2         3       1            3        6          2      7      2         3       1       24          17            
Eur  Autumn Wind         100    0         100    39.1   3         42.1      44     199.99 0.00      199.99 1         1       0            6        5          3      6      1         1       0       22          16            
Eur  Rising Sun          78     0         78     29.2   2.25      31.45     39     159.99 0.00      159.99 1         1       0            8        2          0      8      1         1       0       20          12            
Eur  Teal Dome 2         114    0         114    42     0         42        52     99.99  0.00      99.99  0         1       3            5        5          8      10     0         1       3       32          22            
Eur  East Dome 2         89     0         89     42     0         42        52     149.99 0.00      149.99 0         2       3            7        5          8      8      0         2       3       33          25            
Eur  Wind River 2        142    38        180    42     11        53        48     134.99 40.00     174.99 2         2       3            0        7          5      7      2         2       3       26          19            
Eur  Geom East 1         127    36        163    42     11        53        48     169.99 40.00     209.99 2         3       3            1        7          5      6      2         3       3       27          21            
Eur  Geom EX 3           139    36        175    51     16        67        48     310.00 75.00     385.00 2         3       3            0        10         5      0      2         3       3       23          23            
Eur  Essex 2             132    0         132    38.51  0         38.51     40     169.00 0.00      169.00 0         1       3            4        4          1      7      0         1       3       20          13            
Eur  Sentinel            128    18        146    40     11        51        46     295.00 60.00     355.00 2         3       2            3        7          4      1      2         3       2       22          21            
Eur  Aurora              172    29        201    41     11        52        48     199.00 0.00      199.00 2         1       1            -2       7          5      7      2         0       1       20          13
Eur  Pine Bluff          106    0         106    42     0         42        52     ?                ?      0         1       3            6        5          8      ?      0         0       3       ?           22
Eur  Denali              157    0         157    43     9.95      53        47     299.00 0.00      299.00 1         3       3            2        7          5      3      1         1       3       22          19
Kelt Triple Crown        104    0         104    38.2   18        56.2      49     399.95 0.00      399.95 1         3       2            6        8          6      0      1         3       2       26          26            
Kelt Windfoil-2          101        0     101    41.5   0         41.5      44     400.00 0.00      400.00 0         4       3            6        5          3      0      0         3       3       20          20
LLB  Bean's Dome Tent    120    0         120    42.3   0         42.3      52     89.50  0.00      89.50  0         1       3            5        5          8      10     0         1       3       32          22            
LLB  Expedition Dome     142    0         142    42.3   0         42.3      56     159.00 0.00      159.00 0         3       3            3        5          10     8      0         3       3       32          24            
LLB  Easy-Pitch Geodesic 125    0         125    42.3   0         42.3      53     149.00 0.00      149.00 0         3       3            4        5          8      8      0         3       3       31          23            
Sears 5x7 Pup Tent       56     0         56     35     0         35        42     19.76  0.00      19.76  0         1       2            10       3          2      12     0         0       2       29          17
Sears 6x7 Dome           96     0         96     42     0         42        48     39.94  0.00      39.94  0         1       3            7        5          5      12     0         0       3       32          20

